Do a practical compatibility check when one or both birth times are missing, with clear limits on what astrology can reliably confirm.
Place of birth is optional for Guna Milan. Unknown birth time uses 12:00 noon, which can shift the nakshatra on some days.
Birth time affects the ascendant, house placements, divisional charts, and sometimes the Moon nakshatra. That is why no-time matching should be presented as a preliminary screen.
Guna Milan uses only the Moon's nakshatra, and the Moon moves about 13 degrees a day, so a date of birth alone gives the right nakshatra on most days. If the Moon changed nakshatra on the birth date, the result can be off by one nakshatra — try both a morning and an evening time to see whether the score changes. Lagna, house-based Manglik checks and the 7th house all need an accurate birth time.